Showing posts with label Rwandan Genocide. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rwandan Genocide. Show all posts

Friday, 7 April 2017

'Never again' - 23 years on after Rwandan Genocide

I'm sat here on 6/04/2017 with the overwhelming feeling of having to acknowledge that today 23 years ago, in 1994, the previous government of Rwanda initiated a 100 day bloodshed in which it is estimated that over a million people were slaughtered.

This genocide has always piqued my interest probably because it is the most recent one, happening in the very year that I was born. I first learned about it in a Geography lesson in year 9, where admittedly I had never even heard of the country Rwanda let alone about a genocide that had wiped out a million of its people. You see during primary school and even during secondary school the only genocide we've really learnt about is the Holocaust of the Jews committed by the Nazis. And if I'm perfectly honest even this is not even taught properly. I really do think we neglect to teach and learn about genocides. This should be such an important lesson that is still so relevant in todays society. I have personally heard people say how they don't think such lessons are relevant, believing perhaps naively that society is 'better' and would not repeat the same mistakes. But you have to remember the holocaust of the Jews happened during WW2 and the 'Never Again' slogan began to circulate with members of the UN vowing to step in should another genocide occur. But since then we've had other genocides. We've had the Cambodian genocide in 1975-79, we've had the genocide against kurds in 1988 by the Al-Anfal campaign, we've had the Rwandan genocide in 1994 and right now in 2017 we are seeing genocide happening in Myanmar against the Rohingya muslim. An ongoing genocide that has actually being denied by Aung San Suu Kyi, the Burmese state counsellor of Mayanmar. (Check out Fergal Keane's interview with her here!)  We are seeing Syrian refugees being turned away for fear of them being ‘terrorists’. The Western world seems to pay no hide to the fact that they are escaping from the Assad regime that is killing its own citizens. They seem to focus on the idea that they are ISIS terrorist’s, intent on bringing calamity and destruction into the western world. Turning away from them and refusing to offer a hand of humanity in their time of need is similar to what western world leaders have done in the past regarding humanitarian crises. Thus the 'Never Again' slogan fell on deaf ears in many of those genocides and still seems to fall on deaf ears. 
The world leaders of the western world were notoriously and criticised for their inaction during the Rwandan genocide and rightly so. Their inaction cost the lives of hundreds of thousands of innocent men, women and children who could have been saved if world leaders had backed the UN mission in their greatest time of need.

Skulls and bones of the victims of the Rwanda Genocide


I read that Lieutenant Romeo Dallaire and his troops had actually been tipped off about the extremist's plans to exterminate Tutsi's in January of 1994. A full 3 months before the event! An informant had described how the extremist's had drawn up 'death lists' of people who needed to die, along with information regarding arms caches that were being smuggled into the country illegally. They had even gone as far as to plan the deaths of 10-12 Belgium peacekeepers. Belgium was the backbone of the UNAMIR mission at the time and the plan was to kill Belgium peace keepers in order for Belgium to pull out of the mission completely. This would in effect break the back of the peace keeping mission and eventually the entire UN force would be pulled out leaving the killings to carry on unabated. After hearing of this, Dallaire faxed UN HQ in New York and told them of his intention to raid these arms caches and strike fear into the heart of the extremists that they're were being carefully watched. Straight away UN HQ denied Dallaire the mandate to raid these arm caches and the information from the informant was in effect rubbished by UN HQ in New York. 3 months later, the events described by the informant happened exactly as he had predicted down to the letter. 10 Belgium peacekeepers who were sent to protect the female Hutu moderate prime minister were slaughtered along with the Prime minister herself. Belgium, as predicted by the informant, pulled out of the mission along with many other western countries effectively abandoning Rwanda and its people to their fate.

I often think about this in frustration. 3 months before one of the most tragic and brutal genocides of our generation, Dallaire was given information akin to a diamond mine. Information that could have saved lives and destabilised the genocidal regime. He faithfully entrusted that information to the UN HQ in New York with the expectation that he would be backed when he asked to raid the arms caches. His faith was sadly misplaced. The UN and western world leaders continuously failed Rwanda and its people throughout the genocide and in the years after. In fact, France had been an ally of the government which had perpetrated the genocide. Just before the end of the genocide, France even initiated 'Operation Turquoise' which helped mask the genocidaires, and tons and tons of aid was sent directly into the arms of the killers and perpetrators of the genocide.

The complacency of world leaders in the Rwandan genocide and the genocides since brings me back to the question of whether we can truly say that a genocide will 'Never Again' be allowed to happen. Are we truly a global community where we have learnt from our mistakes and are 'better' than our predecessors or, as Paul Rusesabagina argues, are we still a world community, which finds ways to 'dither in the face of monstrous threats to humanity' (An Ordinary Man, 2006). If so then 'those words Never Again will persist in being one of the most abused phrases in the English Language and one of the greatest lies of our time'.



Ps. I've read a lot on the subject of the Rwandan Genocide since first hearing about it in year 9 from personal accounts of victims, killers to world leaders. I've also seen great documentaries/films based on the subject which I will list in case any of you are interested.

Books

'We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families' Philip Gourevitch: A collection of stories from Rwanda.

'Shake hands with the Devil: The failure of humanity in Rwanda': Lieutenant Romeo's personal account of his experiences in Rwanda as commander of UNAMIR during the genocide.

'An Ordinary man: The true story behind Hotel Rwanda': Paul Rusesabagina personal account of his experience as a hotel manager during the Rwandan genocide and how he managed to shelter 1200 people in his hotel who would have otherwise been slaughtered.

'Miracle in Kigali': Illuminee Nganemariya's personal account of her experience of the Rwandan genocide. She lost her husband to the killers and gave birth to a baby very early on in the Genocide. The book recounts her and her son's survival. Her son, Roger Nsengiyumva is now a very talented British actor.


Films/ Documentaries

'Ghosts of Rwanda': A PBS documentary that documents each day of the genocide with input from victims, perpetrators as well as world leaders, UNAMIR staff  and aid workers. It details the context and history of the country for better understanding how the Rwandan genocide came to be as well as the failings of the world who stood back and allowed over a million people to be slaughtered. I highly recommend watching this and it can be found here!


'Shooting Dogs': A 2005 film set in 'Ecole Technique Officiele' and is based on the experiences of BBC reporter David Belton.

'Hotel Rwanda': A 2004 film based on Paul Rusesabagina's story of sheltering 1200 people in his hotel.

'Shake hands with the Devil': 2007 film based on Romeo Dallaire's experiences as a commander during the Rwandan genocide


'Sometime in April': A 2005 HBO produced historical feature film. It tells the story of two brothers on the opposing sides of the conflict. It stars Idris Elba as a main character. It can be found here!